Third time’s the charm for 1950s-era North York bungalow that fetched over-asking price

A modest three-bedroom bungalow from the 1950s in North York finally sold, and this time, the price was right. After an unsuccessful start, the same eager buyers returned with a third offer and gladly paid well over the asking price. It shows that patience, paired with the right property, can really pay off.

The home, located at 142 Haddington Avenue in North York, was listed in early February 2025 for $1,495,000. Two initial offers didn’t cut it, and the sellers held firm. Then, in early March, the same buyers came back with a third proposal, and this time, the offer hit $1,750,000. That’s a hefty $255,000 above the list price. The house being on a really deep lot and close to schools, a curling club, and easy highways made it a gem that stood out.

The sellers were wise to hold out. Even though turning down offers can be risky, their belief in the property paid off. That appealing patch of land and its handy location near a public school and popular sports facilities made it clear why buyers were committed.

The deep 42-by-130-foot yard gave the home real edge. In Toronto’s tight real estate market, space like that isn’t just rare, it’s valuable. For buyers who had plans to renovate or even rebuild, the room to stretch out made it a serious opportunity.

The sale unfolded in 16 days on the market. That’s quick, but it also meant the property moved fast once the right price was reached. The result: a final sale so strong it tells a bigger story about the demand for homes with potential, especially when they’re priced smart in the first place.

This bungalow’s journey shows how the third time’s the charm approach played out in real life. It speaks to the resilience of sellers and the willingness of buyers to go the extra mile. And it highlights how a property’s location, size, and timing can line up in perfect harmony to bring a rewarding outcome.